A US federal magistrate judge ruled on November 7 that Anthropic must continue facing Claude Max quota misleading consumer claims
The judge rejected Anthropic's argument that the multiples referred to a single usage period, reasoning that monthly subscribers have reason to expect monthly quotas, and that the explanation required two clicks from the main sales page.
On November 7, it was reported that US federal magistrate judge Alex Tse ruled that Anthropic must continue to face the main claims alleging its Claude Max usage quota misled consumers, and dismissed several other requests in the case. Anthropic advertises that its 100 dollar and 200 dollar monthly Max tiers provide 5 times and 20 times the usage of the Pro tier, but consumers who sued in June this year claim that measured across a full week the real quota falls far short of the advertised multiples.
Two plaintiffs, Karl Kahn and Solomon Smith, calculated that for one Claude model the weekly quota on the 200 dollar tier is only 6 times that of Pro, and 3.5 times on the 100 dollar tier. The issue lies in how quota is computed: the 5-hour usage allowance on Max can indeed reach 5 or 20 times that of Pro users, but the weekly cap did not increase proportionally.
Anthropic argued consumers should understand that the advertised multiples refer to a single usage period and cited its help page, a position the judge did not adopt. The ruling states that Anthropic's explanation of a single usage period requires clicking twice through links from the main claude.com sales page. The judge reasoned that since consumers pay a monthly subscription fee, they have reason to believe Anthropic's promised usage quota is also calculated monthly, so plaintiffs may continue to pursue Anthropic's alleged negligent misrepresentation.