Back to news
regulationGoogle2026-11-03

EU court advocate general says Google Gemini use of news reports may infringe copyright

The EU Court advocate general said on November 3 that an LLM chatbot using news articles to generate answers may infringe publisher rights in specific cases, while training use falls under the text and data mining exception.

Reuters reported that an adviser to the European Court of Justice said on November 3 that Google Gemini may breach copyright when it uses news reports to answer questions from internet users in specific circumstances.

The opinion was delivered by Maciej Szpunar, the Advocate General at the EU Court in Luxembourg, in a case brought by Hungarian website operator Like Company against Google, with the dispute focused on how the Gemini chatbot uses news content. An adverse ruling requiring the tech giant to pay for the use of news content would potentially give web publishers such as Like Company a new route to survival.

Szpunar said that when an LLM-driven chatbot retrieves an article from a news publisher website, uses it to generate an answer and presents that answer to users, it may in specific circumstances infringe rights held by the publishing organisation. If the chatbot obtained news content by unlawfully bypassing paywalls or other technical restrictions, or reused the specific expression of news articles in a recognisable way in its answers, Gemini output could infringe the publisher reproduction right. He stressed that copyright does not protect the bare facts in news reports, only the specific expression through which those facts are conveyed.

On the other side, Szpunar considered that using copyright-protected material to train large language models is permitted under the current text and data mining exception. Opinions from the Advocate General are not legally binding, but judges at the court commonly reference and adopt them.

欧盟法院Gemini版权文本与数据挖掘